Hand-checked soccer betting sites, tipsters & stats tools since 201718+ · Please gamble responsibly
+ Submit Your Site
Home › Guides › How to check a tipster

How to check a tipster

Updated 20 November 2026 · 3 min read · by the Sport Betting Directory editors

There are honest tipsters who do real analysis, and there are sellers of dreams. The difference is almost always visible before you pay, if you know where to look. Use this 10-point checklist on any free or paid tipster.

Short answer: trust a tipster only if you can see a complete record with odds, the product and price before paying, and no promises of sure wins. Everything else is a bonus.

The 10-point tipster checklist

  1. Complete public record. Every tip, won and lost, with date, match, market and odds. Not a gallery of winning screenshots.
  2. Odds at the time of the tip. A record is worthless if you could never have got those odds. Spot-check a few on BetExplorer or another odds site.
  3. A long enough sample. 30 tips prove nothing. Look for several hundred tips or at least three to six months.
  4. Profit, not only win rate. “80 % winners” at odds of 1.20 still loses money. Ask for profit in units at a fixed stake, or calculate it.
  5. Clear product before you pay. What exactly do you get (number of matches, market, odds range), when, and for how long?
  6. Transparent price and payment. Price shown up front, normal payment methods such as PayPal or card with buyer protection. Be careful with payment only by gift cards or untraceable transfers.
  7. No “fixed matches”, no “100 % sure”. Anyone claiming inside knowledge of results is lying or breaking the law.
  8. No pressure tactics. Countdown timers, “only 2 places left” and “last chance” messages are sales tricks, not analysis.
  9. Reasoning you can follow. Even paid tips should come with a short explanation: form, team news, statistics.
  10. Responsible gambling. Serious sites say that losses happen, show 18+ notices and link to help such as GambleAware.

Red flags at a glance

Red flag Why it matters
Only winning slips are shown Losses are hidden; the real record is unknown
Record starts again every month Bad months disappear
Odds higher than any bookmaker offered Results are made up or cherry-picked
“Fixed match”, “insider”, “guaranteed” Scam, without exception
Price only after a private chat Price depends on how much they think you will pay
Refund promised “if you lose”, paid as credit You pay again to get the refund

How to calculate a tipster’s real profit

Take the record and assume a fixed stake of 1 unit per tip:

  • For each winner add odds − 1 units.
  • For each loser subtract 1 unit.
  • Divide the total by the number of tips: that is the yield (return per tip).

Example: 100 tips, 55 winners at average odds of 1.90. Profit = 55 × 0.90 − 45 × 1 = 4.5 units, yield 4.5 %. Then subtract what you pay for the tips. A small positive yield over hundreds of tips is realistic; 30 % yield every month is not.

Even good tipsters lose. A real edge of a few percent still produces losing weeks and sometimes losing months. Stake only money you can afford to lose and never chase losses.

Using our fact sheets

For every tipster in our reviews we show the products, the price per day and the payment methods in one place, so you can compare before you pay. Reader reviews are checked by an editor, and buyers who prove an order get a “verified buyer” badge.

FAQ

Are paid tipsters worth it?

Only if their long-term, verifiable profit is higher than their price. Calculate it with the method above before you buy, and start with the cheapest option.

How can I verify a tipster’s record?

Pick ten random tips from the archive, check the result on a livescore site and the odds on BetExplorer or Oddsportal. If several do not match, walk away.

What should I do if I was scammed?

Contact your payment provider quickly (PayPal and card payments can be disputed), keep all messages, and report the site. Do not pay “recovery” services that promise to get your money back.

18+ · Betting involves risk. No tip and no tool can guarantee a win. Bet only what you can afford to lose. Need help? GambleAware · Gambling Therapy

For site owners

Get your site listed

  1. Send your site with the form (category, short description)
  2. Add our link: Sport Betting Directory → sportbettingdirectory.com
  3. We check the site by hand and add it after approval
+ Submit Your Site